All about vunify / vhashify
Some collected wisdom about the vunify/vhashify functionality:
- "unification" is the process of replacing files with hardlinks to identical files in other vservers (or, in the case of vhashify, more precisely to a common base); for security, the files are then supplied with immutable-but-unlinkable flags (a vserver speciality), and recently COW link capability has been added to vserver (2.2+), which means that when such a file is being modified, the hardlink is automatically dissolved and the contents copied (CONFIG_VSERVER_COWBL).
- vhashify is the successor to vunify; vunify only looks at files at identical relative paths and links them if they are identical; vhashify builds hash values over the contents of all (non-excluded) files and links them into a common base directory, or unifies them with pre-existing links there. So running hashification on multiple vservers will effectively hard link their identical files.
- You don't call the vhashify tool directly (which lives in lib/util-vserver/), but let the "vserver" multipurpose script do the work:
vserver <vserver-name> hashify
- The guest needs to be running for the above because vhashify may try to figure out what files not to hashify by calling the package manager of the guest via vserver exec; the reason for this is that it tries not to unify config files because they couldn't be written to afterwards unless COW links are supported (which is a recent addition), which may be a hassle (unlike with program/library files which are not overwritten but replaced on upgrades). The details of how the list of config files is retrieved can be found in scripts/vpkg (lib/util-vserver/vpkg after installation), which is called by the vhashify program (through MatchList_initManually). Currently this means redhat|mandrake and debian are supported. It is looking at a XXX/style file (what's XXX?) for finding out which distribution a guest is running (can this be a problem?) -> open questions to be looked at.
(* If one configures exclude lists, vhashify is supposed not to use package management for getting the config file list -> actually it turns out this is not the case, vserver exec is even being called with an exclude file present. (One can check whether vpkg is being run by adding an echo "$0 $@ called.." >&2 statement at the top of that script. Note the redirection to stderr.))
Be careful to restore the link flags when making or restoring from backups, or vservers won't be safely parted anymore. Do either of the following:
- use tools which backup and restore the link flags ("dump" and "restore" might work, the writer of these lines has not tested them)
- back up the directory containing the hashes, too (/vservers/.hash when following the suggested configuration directives); for restoring from the backup, also restore the .hash directory, then run setattr over all files contained therein; this should work (not yet tested!):
find /vservers/.hash -type f -print0|xargs -0 setattr --iunlink --
- (back up and) restore each vserver individually, so no hardlinks to other vservers are created. Then run hashify. (Be aware that you need more space until hashify has run, so restoring from a backup onto a partition of equal size might not work.)
1Q: <serek> so after cloning, i need to dist-upgrade each vserver separately but finally they will use the same files, right?
1A: <Bertl> you can upgrade all at once or separately, whenever you run vhashify on them, identical data will be linked together
2Q: <serek> may vhashify two existing hosts as well, right?
2A: <Bertl> yep, anytime
3Q: <fluor-> < Bertl> you can upgrade all at once or separately <- what would the "all at once" method be?
3A: <Bertl> depends on the package management, for most common management mechanisms, there is vapt, vyum, and vrpm
Note that "all at once" doesn't mean "simultaneously", just "with a single command". When you mass upgrade your vservers, their identical files won't be hardlinked together until you run vserver hashify again on each of them. This means you'll need a lot more disk space until you vhashify. And don't forget to remove hashed files that no longer have other hard links.